and wouldn't it be lovely,
if we could breathe in the ocean,
harboring rolling foam in our aching souls, soothing
aspirin to our cracks and bones
I'm sure there's plenty of room in
your hollowed out heart for fish and
sand, salty lovers, a captain's dream
in a place I found no solace
you are loveless, prettier than
pearl and not worth as much. singing skeletons
to sleep every night must have made you
falter, because there is no such thing as giving up,
giving in,
only bowing down to let the whale
swallow you whole
and wouldn't it be lovely,
if we could remember, I don't know,
I don't know, I want to remember.
we used to be in love.
Here's what I could figure, the whole thing is about 2 former lovers. The narrator is dictating a analysis on what their relationship was, could've been and where they are now being apart. The narrator is looking on her former lover with pity, his life now a far cry from where he was when they were together. Singing skeletons to sleep, maybe hints at his sexual activity now and that curious phrase in the third stanza no "giving up, no giving in" seems to be referring to romance [in that there is no way to really take oneself out of the romantic game, so its impossible to quit, you just move from different form to form of romance]. The most puzzling piece of imagery is in the first stanza, the idea of breathing in the ocean obviously refers to the future they could've had, but what that is I can only take a stab at.
Here's what I can figure, this guy was a total loser before he met her. He was worthless, and probably felt that way about himself too but she saw in him that with the empowerment that the love of a woman can provide he could have a great capacity to love. They got together but their relationship splintered, possibly because he loved her too much. You get the feeling that singing skeletons to sleep, and the whale he's bowed down to means he's turned to things like prostitution to satisfy his desires. But unlike his time with her its empty. He's looking for a companion, someone who he can cling to and will cling to him. She may be looking towards parenthood that he could be the guy she can have a family with [that's my guess on what breathing in the ocean is]; but he sees that as something he doesn't want. He just wants her, all the time with no distractions and added responsibilities, the kind that occur when you have kids and family.
So they break up, she moves on, but he is perhaps worse off. Probably struggling to find a woman who doesn't want kids and can appreciate his clingy nature he turns to hookers and the like. She can't help but pity and remember that he was capable of love, and that she loved him too. I think maybe she's a bit sorry that he can't find a person to share his life with in the way he wants to.
Good stuff as usual.
I'll admit, this is a pretty confusing one. I don't even think I truly understand what I meant. You're right though, it is about two former lovers, and where they are now. They could have been so much more, but he didn't know how to handle love properly. In a way, he broke it. He "gave up", but as it mentions, there is no such thing as giving up, not when it comes to love. It's not something you can intentionally forget about. It's the cowards way out, the way he took, and the line "...in a place I found no solace" shows that. There's potential for love, for greatness, for that happiness that should be above everything else...but that was all rejected. For no damn good reason either.
The perplexing thing was why they broke up. Ultimately it feels like the poem is just saying that they both wanted different things. So to say he took the easy way out, and he didn't handle love properly, that can be hard to see without the exact reason why he walked away. It seems like she thought they could handle greater responsibilities together so maybe she's thinking family etc., but he was maybe more carefree and wanted them to have a hedonistic type thing where they had few responsibilities and lived to make each other happy. But those are really sketches and not exact pictures...
This is gorgeous, woman.
Thank you!!